Are We Doing Any Good?

By Building Impact
|
11 / 25 / 19

Consider the spectrum of philanthropic giving you or others in your social circle made over the last five years: You may be thinking of gifts to alma maters. Or, you’re thinking of a GoFundMe campaign for someone you knew who had an accident, those soccer team fundraising drives, or an end-of-year large donation to a nonprofit. Maybe you’re thinking of a political moment over the past few years that led you to whip out your wallet first and then figure out where to send the cash. 

One of the most common questions we get from clients is “Are my resources truly having an impact on the change I want to see in the world?” Naturally, no matter the size of the gift, as a giver, you want to know that whatever you’re giving to is making a meaningful difference. Philanthropists, especially those with a business background are used to having straightforward metrics to measure their success (e.g., ROI, net profit). In the realm of driving social change and making a positive impact on society through philanthropy, the metrics can be far less concrete, clear, or direct. 

So why is philanthropy so different?

There are two big reasons measuring change in philanthropy feels so different from other sectors. First, accountability for results of any kind continues to be optional in philanthropy. Donors, in all shapes and sizes, give simply because they want to. In many cases the “return” on such giving is not evaluated in any formal way. Rather, success is often measured by feelings – does it bring the giver joy to give to this cause? Is the recipient happy and grateful? 

Second, even those who do strive for more objective accountability around results struggle with how to measure impact when dealing with complex social problems. These philanthropists find themselves wondering, “Am I actually having an impact?” “How will I know if my resources are driving real, sustainable, and positive change?” These questions are so prevalent among philanthropists that they have driven the development of many online guides and other efforts to assess grantee performance (e.g., GiveWellCharity NavigatorGuideStar). These tools can be a helpful piece of the puzzle, but still do not provide a comprehensive picture of overall impact. 

At Building Impact, we believe that the ultimate measure of philanthropy’s success is the positive social change it produces – and this can be challenging to measure, especially using traditional methods. For example, we work with many philanthropists who have goals to transform education systems in a particular region to better serve the needs of all kids. Educators use a host of traditional metrics to measure success (e.g., test results, teacher retention, graduation rates), but those alone will not provide the concrete answer to whether in fact the education system is better serving the needs of all kids. Measuring the true success of an effort at instigating systemic change is not easy, given all of the factors that could impact student performance measures, the inability to tie results back directly to increased giving, and the reality that success has not been universally defined in such a context. Measuring impact yield insights that help advance our understanding of the issue and drive how we think about philanthropy and the problem we are hoping to address. That said, doing so is rarely, if ever, straightforward.

What are some ways you can measure the success of social change?

Below are a few strategies we’ve found that help change agents successfully determine whether they are on the right course. In our experience, it is important to recognize that in the same way highly complex issues require sophisticated and customized strategies, so does the challenge of measuring impact in these same fields require a customized approach:

  • Develop your metrics of success with the people whom you are hoping to impact and/or those who are already being impacted by the issues you desire to change. The most powerful and effective philanthropists recognize the limits of their own perspective and work to continually expand their understanding of the world and the problems they are seeking to impact. There’s no better way to do that than to engage directly with those who are impacted by the potential solutions you are funding.
  • Identify those things that ARE easily measurable, determine which are most important, and measure them. These will often be inputs, a measure of effort (e.g. number of students served), or outputs, a measure of what is produced (e.g. test scores, graduation rates, etc.). Taken as part of a whole, these inputs can yield valuable insights.
  • For the things that are harder to measure, consider the conditions that are necessary for the type of social change you want to see to occur. In our work, we often refer to SSIR’s framework for assessing advocacy as a helpful reference point, which is at the heart of most social change work. The basic idea is that if we focus on the conditions that need to be present for the change to be successful – having powerful political champions for change, a mobilized public, and a feasible solution, for example – then we’re more likely to effect that change. One way to measure progress then is determining whether those conditions are present – and working to create them if they are not. 
  • Take the time to develop both near- AND long-term measures. Too many philanthropists settle for near-term grant cycle metrics that don’t leave room for “failing forward” using past challenges to inform future innovation. When you have a long-term plan and are keyed in to measure results over many years, short term setbacks aren’t quite so catastrophic — and may in fact yield crucial insights.

Stop asking “Are we doing any good?” We promise it will help.

We’re so used to asking ourselves, “Are we doing any good?” Instead, we should ask “How can I do better?” This questions is goal-oriented and outcome-minded — just as we want our philanthropy to be. When seeking to harness philanthropy to do its very best in the face of complex social challenges, staying both humble and hopeful is key. We will almost never be satisfied by our first efforts — but if we are committed to learning, coming back and continuously improving our understanding and our giving, we are maximizing our chances of truly doing good in the long run. 

Share

More Insights & Resources

In 2021, at the height of a global pandemic, 98 new billionaires joined the Forbes list in America alone. Collectively,...
By Alex Johnston
|
12 / 14 / 23
This holiday season my wife and I are celebrating our 15th wedding anniversary. Ever the philosopher, my 13-year-old son asked...
By Mike Wang
|
12 / 08 / 23
Over the last eleven years, we’ve had the privilege at Building Impact to partner with incredible donors and other changemakers...
By Building Impact
|
10 / 20 / 23
A few weeks ago I shared some data about the demographics and giving habits of the ultra wealthy on my...
By Alex Johnston
|
12 / 15 / 22
One of the biggest barriers to giving, and giving effectively, is the American taboo around talking about money and wealth....
By Alex Johnston
|
08 / 24 / 22
Recently, a well-respected philanthropist came to me on a mission to find more meaning in her giving. Many like her...
By Mike Wang
|
07 / 20 / 22
I started 2022 with an impossible goal—a goal that felt so unlikely, so totally implausible, that it was laughable in its...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
04 / 24 / 22
In my neighborhood in Philadelphia, the effort to improve a physically dangerous, unattractive thoroughfare has come to illustrate one of...
By Mike Wang
|
03 / 02 / 22
This month, I returned from maternity leave after having my third child in October. With my first two children, I...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
01 / 25 / 22
As 2021 draws to a close, one of the year’s bright spots for me was the AppleTV show, Ted Lasso. At...
By Mike Wang
|
12 / 07 / 21
Here’s what that means and why it can be incredibly fulfilling for you as a donor. One big reason funders...
By Alex Johnston
|
11 / 24 / 21
Before any reports came out detailing the extent of the academic impact of the pandemic on students, education leaders were...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
09 / 16 / 21
As school systems around the country manage the challenge of returning to in-person instruction amidst the surging Delta variant and...
By Mike Wang
|
09 / 01 / 21
Over the past few years, a variety of leaders in philanthropy have been calling for funders to embrace more risk in their...
By Alex Johnston
|
08 / 03 / 21
So you’ve decided you want your philanthropy to be more transformative. Or innovative. Or to better live up to your aspirations...
By Mike Wang
|
06 / 21 / 21
One of the biggest barriers to high impact philanthropy is the fact that the people with the most  financial resources are rarely...
By Alex Johnston
|
05 / 20 / 21
To white people, from another white person –  I’m white, and I grew up in a predominantly white and wealthy...
By Molly Barnes
|
04 / 30 / 21
In America, we tend to believe that enough money can fix any problem. Who hasn’t sat around thinking, “If I...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
04 / 09 / 21
“We just can’t work with them anymore. Their political views are repugnant, even if they were with us before…”  “…But...
By Mike Wang
|
03 / 05 / 21
The last few years have seen an increasingly public critique of philanthropy, with books like Just Giving by Rob Reich, Decolonizing Wealth by Edgar...
By Alex Johnston
|
01 / 25 / 21
Search