Building coalitions for social change amid political turmoil

By Mike Wang
|
03 / 05 / 21

“We just can’t work with them anymore. Their political views are repugnant, even if they were with us before…” 

“…But they’ve been an ally on our issue. We can’t afford to lose them. We should just look past the areas where we disagree…” 

I hear this exchange play out again and again, and never more than in the aftermath of the most rancorous election in recent history. 

Philanthropists and the nonprofits they fund are asking, Where do we draw the line when it comes to who we will work with? What happens when our partners are on the other side of divisive issues or hold objectionable political views?

There are no simple answers to these questions. 

On the one hand, most experienced advocates recognize that lasting change is most likely to happen through broad-based coalitions, even when that means partnering across lines of ideological difference. Being too ideologically pure about who you’re willing to work with can limit your effectiveness.

On the other hand, there are times when working with those whose words and actions run counter to your goals can result in more harm than good. As an example, I’ve noticed that some political leaders who believe that school systems do not serve Black students well have also supported measures to disenfranchise Black voters; to engage in the latter undermines the former. And we shouldn’t be afraid to call that out. 

How can funders and the nonprofits they support navigate this tension? 

Focus on the issue, rather than picking a team.

Coalition partners working together on specific issues must be able to differ — sometimes vocally — on other issues. True, you may ruffle some feathers along the way, but savvy funders, politicians, and nonprofits recognize that ideological purity doesn’t get results. It is critical for funders, in particular, to consider the power dynamic between themselves and their grantees and create space for grantees who hold different views. In turn, grantees shouldn’t forget the power they have to engage with funders to challenge and shape their perspective. Grantees who refuse funding because of ideological differences with their donors could forfeit an opportunity to change the perspectives of those funders. 

Get crystal clear around the problem you are solving for.

Then use that clarity to figure out what lines you simply cannot cross in order to remain in service of your cause. Alliances of convenience focused more on, say, a particular policy than on solving a problem at its root run the risk of undermining their own long-term objectives for expediency’s sake. Most coalitions have little trouble finding common ground, but the trick to making coalitions sustainable is understanding where partners disagree and when those disagreements will stand in the way of collaboration. 

Revisit the question of whether and how to work together often.

The political conditions that shape how we create change evolve constantly. It may be effective to work with one group today and not tomorrow. Regularly reassess your landscape and adjust your strategy accordingly. Find new allies who were previously opponents and recognize that when a longstanding partnership begins to undermine your credibility or your cause, it may be time to move on. 

Political partisanship and single-issue litmus tests are overly simplistic and unhelpful frameworks when it comes to creating lasting change. At the same time, a shared past or political affiliation shouldn’t lock you in to an unhelpful partnership. Knowing when to partner and when to break with those partners is an essential skill for funders and change agents who want to maximize their impact. 

Share

More Insights & Resources

In social impact work we tend to wear many hats, but I was recently surprised to learn how many of...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
08 / 09 / 24
No one philanthropist or foundation can do everything well, and no one philanthropist or foundation can solve all of the...
By Tanis Klingler
|
06 / 28 / 24
As a working mom with four kids under seven, I’ve learned to adjust the expectations I have for motherhood. My...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
03 / 25 / 24
In 2021, at the height of a global pandemic, 98 new billionaires joined the Forbes list in America alone. Collectively,...
By Alex Johnston
|
12 / 14 / 23
This holiday season my wife and I are celebrating our 15th wedding anniversary. Ever the philosopher, my 13-year-old son asked...
By Mike Wang
|
12 / 08 / 23
Over the last eleven years, we’ve had the privilege at Building Impact to partner with incredible donors and other changemakers...
By Building Impact
|
10 / 20 / 23
A few weeks ago I shared some data about the demographics and giving habits of the ultra wealthy on my...
By Alex Johnston
|
12 / 15 / 22
One of the biggest barriers to giving, and giving effectively, is the American taboo around talking about money and wealth....
By Alex Johnston
|
08 / 24 / 22
Recently, a well-respected philanthropist came to me on a mission to find more meaning in her giving. Many like her...
By Mike Wang
|
07 / 20 / 22
I started 2022 with an impossible goal—a goal that felt so unlikely, so totally implausible, that it was laughable in its...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
04 / 24 / 22
In my neighborhood in Philadelphia, the effort to improve a physically dangerous, unattractive thoroughfare has come to illustrate one of...
By Mike Wang
|
03 / 02 / 22
This month, I returned from maternity leave after having my third child in October. With my first two children, I...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
01 / 25 / 22
As 2021 draws to a close, one of the year’s bright spots for me was the AppleTV show, Ted Lasso. At...
By Mike Wang
|
12 / 07 / 21
Here’s what that means and why it can be incredibly fulfilling for you as a donor. One big reason funders...
By Alex Johnston
|
11 / 24 / 21
Before any reports came out detailing the extent of the academic impact of the pandemic on students, education leaders were...
By Caitlin Hannon
|
09 / 16 / 21
As school systems around the country manage the challenge of returning to in-person instruction amidst the surging Delta variant and...
By Mike Wang
|
09 / 01 / 21
Over the past few years, a variety of leaders in philanthropy have been calling for funders to embrace more risk in their...
By Alex Johnston
|
08 / 03 / 21
So you’ve decided you want your philanthropy to be more transformative. Or innovative. Or to better live up to your aspirations...
By Mike Wang
|
06 / 21 / 21
One of the biggest barriers to high impact philanthropy is the fact that the people with the most  financial resources are rarely...
By Alex Johnston
|
05 / 20 / 21
To white people, from another white person –  I’m white, and I grew up in a predominantly white and wealthy...
By Molly Barnes
|
04 / 30 / 21
Search